THE COUNTDOWN IS ON — OPENING OCTOBER 6! 🧀
ROOTED IN TRADITION SINCE 1924
A Tradition Worth
Sharing
Discover quality cheeses, specialty foods, party trays
and thoughtful gift boxes made for gathering,
celebrating and sharing.
A beloved cheese-house tradition,
entering a new chapter.
Our Story...
The Old World Cheese House was inspired by a love for tradition, quality, and the simple joy that good food brings to people. What started as a passion for exceptional cheese and specialty foods has grown into a place where neighbors, families, and friends can gather, discover, and create delicious memories together
A TRADITION WORTH PRESERVING
Rooted in 1924.
Ready for a New Chapter.
For generations, this cheese house has been part of the community -
bringing quality cheese, specialty foods, and welcoming experience to
customers who appreciate good food and traditions worth keeping.
Today, that tradition continues under a new name:
THE OLD WORLD CHEESE HOUSE.
While the name is new, the heart of the cheese house remains rooted in
the values that have made it special for generations: quality, craftmanship,
family, and community.
SOMETHING FOR EVERY TABLE
Good Cheese. Good Company.
Whether you're planning a celebration, looking for the perfect gift, or
simply treating yourself, there's something waiting for you at The Old World Cheese House.
Specialty Cheeses
Explore a selection of quality cheeses
chosen for flavor, variety and
every kind of cheese lover.
Party Trays
Make your next gathering deliciously
memorable with a thoughtfully prepared
cheese tray made for sharing.
Gift Boxes
Give something they'll truly enjoy. Our gift boxes are thoughtfully prepared for holidays, celebrations and special moments.
MEET THE NEW CHAPTER
Meet Catherine & Tim
We're honored to carry this beloved cheese-house tradition into it's next chapter.
When Catherine & Tim Levengood took ownership of the business, they saw an opportunity to preserve what makes this place special while giving it a fresh identity for the future.
Their goal is simple:
Honor the tradition. Serve the community.
Create something worth passing forward.
We look forward to welcoming familiar faces and new friends to The Old World Cheese House.
Our Mission
To provide our community with exceptional cheeses and thoughtfully prepared specialty foods while preserving the warmth, craftsmanship, and tradition of a true neighborhood cheese house.
We are committed to serving every customer with quality products, genuine hospitality, and the personal care that makes every visit feel like coming home.
Our Vision
To become a beloved destination for cheese lovers and families—honoring a tradition that began in 1924 while creating new memories and traditions for generations to come.
We envision The Old World Cheese House as a place where
quality, community, and the simple joy of sharing good
food continue to bring people together.
WHY CUSTOMERS COMEBACK
We believe good food starts
with quality ingredients and
thoughtful selection.
Rooted in a history that dates back to 1924, we value the traditions that make a cheese house special.
We're proud to be part of the community and the moments that bring people together.
From choosing the perfect cheese
to preparing a special tray, we're
here to help.
MADE FOR GATHERINGS
Build a Cheese Tray
Worth Sharing.
Planning a birthday, holiday, family gathering, office event,
wedding celebration, or simply a night with friends?
Let us help you create a party tray made for your occasion.
Choose from a variety of cheeses and specialty foods to
create spread your guests will love.
GIVE THE GIFT OF GOOD TASTE
Thoughtful Gifts.
Delicious Memories.
Looking for a gift that's a little different?
Our cheese and specialty food gift boxes are perfect for birthdays, holidays, thank you's, celebrations, corporate gifting, or simply showing someone you care.
THERE'S ALWAYS SOMETHING
DELICIOUS TO DISCOVER.
From everyday favorites to specialty selections, we love helping customers
discover something new to enjoy.
Whether you know exactly what you're looking for or need a little help choosing, stop by and let us help you find the perfect addition to your table.
A NEW CHAPTER BEGINS
Come Celebrate With us on October 6, 2026
Join us as we open the doors to The Old World Cheese House and continue a tradition rooted in quality, community, and good food. Come discover our cheeses, specialty foods, and thoughtfully prepared offerings made for sharing
CONTACT US
WE'D LOVE TO HEAR FROM YOU!
Have question? Need directions? We're here to help!
Come visit us at the same location and continue the tradition of great cheese , snacks and friendly service.
OUR LOCATION
2229 Stonecreek Road SW
New Philladelphia, OH 44663
PHONE
330-339-5067
Feel free to reach out with any questions!
DIRECTIONS
I-77 North to Stonecreek (exit #73). Turn left. Approximately 4.5 miles on the Right.
I-77 South to New Philadelphia (exit #81) Turn right. Approximately 4.5 miles on the Left.
HOURS
Tuesday-Friday 10am-5pm
Saturday 10am-3pm
Sunday- Monday- Closed
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes! While we have a new name and new owners, we’re continuing the traditions, quality, and welcoming experience that our community has loved for generations. We’re excited to begin this new chapter as The Old World Cheese House.
You can find us at:
2229 Stonecreek Road SW
New Philadelphia, OH 44663
Come visit us and discover your next favorite cheese!
We offer a variety of quality cheeses and specialty foods, along with party trays and gift boxes. Whether you're shopping for your family, planning a gathering, or looking for a delicious gift, we've got something worth sharing.
Absolutely! Our party trays are perfect for family gatherings, celebrations, holidays, parties, and special occasions. Contact us with your event details, and we'll help you plan the perfect tray.
COPYRIGHTS 2026 | THEOLDWORLDCHEESEHOUSE | TERMS & CONDITIONS